Drowned in Sound

Search



jesse malin on your sleeve
8 votes
?
by Jordan Dowling

Let me say one thing at the outset: if not for the fact that my words would be disregarded as knee-jerk and intentionally reactionary, I would have no qualms giving On Your Sleeve, the latest album by Brooklyn-based 'folk-rock troubadour' type Jesse Malin, a nice round zero.

It is without question one of the most infuriatingly bland albums released this year; a covers album reworking songs from such luminaries as The Rolling Stones, The Kills and Harry Nilsson ('Everybody's Talking', click for the original) into identikit pieces even more soulless and middle-of-the-road than the originals.

But the main problem isn't necessarily just Jesse's tendency to make every song sound near enough exactly like the ones preceding and following it, but the incessantly grating nature of his voice, which goes between Jon Bon Jovi tribute posturing on 'Russian Roulette' and overstated mouth full of oranges crooning on Lou Reed's 'Walk On The Wild Side'.

And although this album contains none of his own material it holds up the perfect expositional spotlight to Jesse Malin's horrifically generic one-dimensional songwriting structure, and even hardcore fans of the Springsteen wannabe will be struggling to find anything to enjoy in the 14 tracks that span the length of On Your Sleeve, an album as close to a dictionary-standard definition of the word mediocre as there is likely to be in the whole of 2008.

  • Jesse Malin 4 / 10
Words: Jordan Dowling

i'm that hardcore fan

And I really like the Russian Roulette cover so... nyer!


nyer?

don't make me declare a thumb war..


you'd beat me

I am a pathetic girl about these things.


well

i have no thumbs..


great review...

Ouch...


good point

it is a great review...


Sorry, but Couldn't Disagree More.

Wow. This review really threw me... I find it hard to believe we listened to the same album! I really like this album and found that Jesse's take on a few of the tracks here to be really fresh. I gave this one a very positive review on my webpage.

Of course you are welcome to your opinion but your review really sounds like you are someone who doesn't particularly care for Jesse Malin to begin with. If that's the case, it's not really a fair assessment. I would suggest anyone interested in the record to give it a spin and make up your own mind.