Drowned in Sound

Search



the "is this band any good" thread

no votes
?
by Dicko

post a band here (no jags) and find out if they're any good.

i've heard good things about grammatics and MGMT, are either any good?

Dicko | 28 Mar '08, 17:17 | Send note | Report this | Reply

MGMT = Great Singles band

forgetable album

Tokyo Police Club?


I like tokyo police club

because i've heard one of their songs, and i thought that it was rather good. This may not be the strongest recommendation that you hear for them, but i'm afraid that it's the best that i've got.

Dirty Projectors?


^ O i have heard them but didnt know what others thought in general, im interested :D

Dirty Projectors are excelent!

They have such a good and unique vocal delivery


Eeeexcellent

(rubs hands together)

Thanks, i'll add this information to any excitement that i might be feeling about Field Day.


Dirty Projectors

were awful when I saw them live...


(stops rubbing hands together)

(frowns)

hmmmm


tokyo police club are good.

they have a great vocalist.


I like grammatics ( good fun but nothing really special )

I hated what I heard of MGMT...


why

don't you trust your own ears and listen for yourself?


because

you can't judge a band on a few songs. and it's nice to get an opinion :)


But

virtually everyone who posts opinions in these threads will have judged the bands on a few songs anyway.


maccabees?

i've never listened to them. worth a listen?


Yes!!!

they are unforutenetly lumped in with a scene that the NME backs, therefor music snobs hate them by default :)


oh god

i hate it when that happens :(


The Maccabees

are also bloody good live.


I agree they are better thanmost of that "scene"

But the album isn't really that good.


im a

n00b. what is a jag?/jags?

and i think the maccabees might be quite good. it seems that a good song gets played on the radio. and i say 'ooh. who is that?' and someone says 'thats the maccabees.' and i think: ooh.


bands I couldn't be bothered listening to

I don't understand why people don't just search for their website, go to a blog aggegator and stream something, or choose their own music with their brain!!


That said

are psychedelic horseshit any good?


Nope

total Vice band.


a band who

are all style/no substance?


hm. i wouldn't say they have style!

they're just crazy :)


Square


haha

what the fuck!?


Yes, they're great

dischordant and noisy. Complete car crash of a band.


lets see

MGMT = yes
Grammatics = saw them live, didn't particularly enjoy them