thought this would be interesting, alot of bands on here, all of us trying to chase the elusive deal (or maybe not) what do you do to further your bands progress might help other people get a jist or point out how not to waste your time.
i'll dive in..
write,record in our rat infest of a lockup 3-4 times week, play as many gigs as possible, whenever where ever..
sit at work all day emailing people, sending out promos, in the hope they will listen and come along to show..
sound about right?
what are other peoples ideas on what a band should do to get "signed"
Depends what you want from it........
Is your end goal to 'get signed' or to be great at what you do?
I would suggest that it's always better to focus on the latter, then if the former occurs, all well and good.
Plenty of rubbish bands get signed and implode long before a sophomore album is even written.
There are parallels with skateboarding (wait, hear me out!), I used to know so many people who were obsessed with 'getting sponsored', they forgot why they got into it in the first place, because it's great!
Totally agree
My band spent 4 years desperate to get signed and in the end it ruined us and we split up.
Now we just play music because we love it and try and be as good as we can be. Whatever happens happens.
Getting signed is about 10% talent, 90% luck.
The skateboarding analogy
is pretty relevant actually.
But i guess it relates to quite a lot of sports as well
you have to play ALL the time
to get your name known. Certainly in London. I've been told this by numerous music people that this is important.
Having your own club night helps as well, if you think about it many indie bands over the last few years have had their own club nights (Kaiser Chiefs, Clor, The Horrors) this helps you build contacts and make friends with other bands, and essentially "build a scene" if you're booking bands with a certain aesthetic.
And of course writing good songs is hte most important thing.
I do kind of feel a bit jaded with the music industry though as everyone i know who are signed either know someone quite high up in the music industry or are related to someone who already is in music (for example the nephew of the singer of Shakespeare's Sister). Or they are very rich.
But if you can't beat them, join em! I've joined a band recently who have shitloads of contacts in the music industry and know lots of famous bands personally. If we can consistantly write decent songs maybe we'll be okay...
i don't think playing gigs all the time necessarily works
where's the myth if someone has played a lot already? i think playing the right gigs has a different kind of potency, as it's not how many people see you but who sees you, if that makes sense.
yep
Sean's totally on the money there. Plus playing lots of gigs in London DESTROYS YOUR SOUL. Well it did mine anyway.
i can give you a few recent examples of bands who have done this though and have done relatively wel
One More Grain
Partyshank
Ipso Facto
All i think are quite niche sort of bands and not the sort that are gonna have a top 40 single anytime soon, but all are doing well and have had a lot of press and i'm pretty sure most people on these boards have at least heard of them and have an opinion on them, and may have even seen them play.
I'm sure there are loads of bands who have done the complete opposite and have just been lucky enough to find someone really quickly.
But i do actually agree with you Sean, in bands i've played in we've always been very picky with our gigs, luckily we were always in a position to be picky and never once did we have to send out any demos or contact people to play for them. Still, with every potential music manager we've met the first thing they tell us is that we should be gigging week in and week out. As much as i love playing i wouldn't want to do it to the point where i become jaded and bored of playing to people, and we much prefered promoting the fuck out of the gigs we did do and trying to make each individual gig special (new songs, outfits, etc) so it would be exciting for everyone involved.
it's simple
don't tell anyone about your band until you've got good (see also all the slagging george pringle gets on here because people saw her play her first gig or simply it's no their thing). wait until you've found someone to help develop what you do and bare in mind it took kate bush 3 albums of major label funded development to get proper good. so by this i don't mean good by some friend who vaguely likes music and comes to your gigs standards but good that you all honestly believe what you're doing is as good as you aspire for it to be and its ready to sit alongside your heroes and not because you sound exactly like them. music is just going to standstill if people don't start raising the bar so i think this is really important that any bands ambition should be about being something special, rather than about being 'signed' or "making it, whatever that means..."
then don't go sending your music to labels, that's everyones first mistake. aim for the periphery, that's how you start a buzz and make people want to hear your band. think about how you've heard about music and how you develop a natural relationship with it, that's exactly how a&r people work too, they either have a vision or they act like a sheep and very few people have vision (kaiser chiefs were rubbished as some tuneless also-ran at their first post-parva gigs and no a&r would touch bat for lashes). you can build the buzz by giving stuff away and doing what los campesinos and year before them mystery jets did on these boards but not really jagging themselves but being part of the furniture.
first, when you've hopefully found a nice producer to give you a day or two to produce something half-decent sounding, you should send it to the booking agents, press officers, lawyers and managers of your favourite acts - most of whom are now easy to track down because of the web or just turn up to the bands show and give the band a copy each (easily done via the merch stall) and add an extra copy for their manager and the gigs promoter so that hopefully you can get some supports if they like what you do.
be sure that the package looks and feels special, it's worth working a few extra shifts or taking money from a show to ensure the first impression is intriguing. pay a graphic designer or artsy friend either some money or do some of their chores or something. i know it sounds crap but i remember johnny borrell handing out his demo wrapped in a bow to everyone in the guestlist queue when yeah yeah yeahs played the barfly and it did, it seems, get him some gig offers and a manager, who then helped do the rest.
however, having said that, the above only makes sense if you wanna sign to a major and to be honest, getting a record deal isn't the be all and end all nowadays, not even bands 'on the map' as it were can get deals or make money doing what they're doing. youthmovies, redjetson, thisgirl and jeniferever all lost me a lot of money, despite the fact they were released on really small budgets but even small is still about £30k just to cash flow the release and staff involved in it and yet you're still the bad guy, who gets all the blame when the distributer cocks up or vans breakdown or the press give a bad review or you're not at every london gig and get little thanks when they don't sell enough records to break even (with about £4 now coming back from the distributer per record that's about 7000 record sales and the last sonic youth barely sold 10,000...). and yet i love and am really proud of releasing all the above records but you can see why it doesn't make sense to release any more of them when it's so quick and easy for people to share and download a record for free.
ps
My advice, in short, is make music because you have to.
people are always complaining...
And labels are always accused of being the devil.
Remember when Peace Burial at Sea were dropped...
i think some of this is a bit unfair
esp the George Pringle comments.
I think it's really hard to know as an artist when you are 'good' or 'ready'. Most people don't have critical distance when it comes to their own performances.
Aside from DiS, where lets face it, we do all similar taste formations (weird that); outside of this little indie bubble, people have far wider tastes. I mean look at Razorlight and even, to cite your example, the Kaiser Chiefs I don't know very many DiS regulars who'd admit to liking either of those bands, and they're really commercially successful these days.
Otherwise great advice tho! :)
ok
i admit i've made sweeping generalizations in order to try to be as succinct as possible, it's an extremely complex argument.
what have you hit on is something i tell people a lot of the time, it's that just because your band is better than The View, it doesn't mean your band are special or even good.
:)
Sweeping generalisations are sometimes necessary!
I think it really depends on who, in a position of power, thinks your band is good, and how willing they are to put their reputations on the line for your band. Look at John Peel!
Nowadays tho, there's so many people using this sort of celeb 'taste' factor to increase listeners to radio shows. E.g Zane Lowe (Or any Radio1 dj) does blow the trumpets of some great bands (IMHO), but he for many shit bands (IMHO). Whut'cha think?
On a side subject, are DiS records not releasing any singles no longer? I know you just released Ymovies album and MW's is in the pipeline?
we're just doing RCRD LBL / Drownload releases
some of which we send stuff out to the press and media about in advance to make them more single like. but sadly there's no real reward for the time/money invested in doing singles, especially if there's no real album to follow. no-one really knows we did a single for emmy or adam gnade or blood red shoes and they only really know about bat for lashes and kaisers singles because i go on about it, so in terms of it increasing the awareness of dis it doesn't really work, especially as what i like and put time/money into, is increasingly different to what the editorial team likes. i'm currently setting up a new project and v.likely to be closing the label soon, especially as i don't think the 'record' business makes sense to be in any longer.
i don't think anyone puts their balls on the line anymore, least not without enough buzz or the right people behind something to be sure - see also the tuneless abomination which can barely play their instruments that is black kids who're managed by the people behind bjork/arcade fire.
where are the tony wilson's and malcolm mclarens or even alan mcgee's of this era? in an age where everything is more do-able than ever it seems people are content to run a blogspot blog read by a few hundred people, giving away material they have no real right to do so...
I like that RCRD LBL / Drownload site
that was a very savvy call on your part. :) I hear singles are dying a slow death. Was it Zavvi who have just deleted them from their shelves? I'm one of those people who won't buy a phsyical single (i might download - itunes- the odd song i like). I do feel they'll soon be gone.
That's a shame about the DiS label possibly closing. I've always thought it was a really brilliant label who pioneered some really great artists (but then I like Metric, BfL, BRS, Jeniferever and Ymovies so i would say that).
I don't think anyone in the mainstream puts their balls on the line anymore. But I think that is largely why these people are in the positions they are, because they've done enough hype kissing during their careers to be able to stay there.
I don't know Black Kids. Might have to check them out for the baddness (?).
I think people who do still put their balls on the line, are more likely to be found supporting bands in your locality. So people like Ady (above) who has put on some really wicked bands in the Oxford area. BSM (also in this thread) have also signed the likes of TTNG and Yndi Halda. These are the people who put the bands on/sign them, that people like myself and yourself happen to find out about through their mailing lists probably. If you want a London example, Look at Moshi Moshi. x
there are plenty of labels that put their money where their mouth is
they just don't / can't get the press coverage that bigger labels can command.
god guntrip!!!
I don't agree actually. I think it's never been easier to get media coverage on reputable sites (websites are probably easier than your kerrangs/rocksounds/NMEs). Some like DiS have a huge number of daily hits (the website equiv of circulation). There's no excuse really. Not to dwell too much on personal experience, but i deal far more with independent labels than I do with majors.
"There's no excuse really. "
hahahaha.
the press is a lot more fractured that it used to be, and there are probably more labels active now than, well, ever. and loads of them put out fuckloads of good stuff that just doesn't get the coverage it should by dint of who is releasing it. and that's without going into the boom-and-bust hype cycles that pretty much all strata of the press are sold on these days.
even sites like DiS can be hard to break into! we're doing an album for a band that has had a decent amount of DiS coverage in the past and all our mailouts go to DiS' news inbox but we never got a story out of it.
if you're doing things for yourself on a part time basis and a shoestring hudget it's really, really hard to get coverage beyond basic reviews.
do you work in press or something?
plus
it's not helped by how the way a lot of indie labels are run has totally changed, yet the perception of them hasn't. labels like transgressive and young & lost are still touted as banner holders for the 'indie' side when all their $$$ comes from major labels.
who's the band?
I'll be nice and check them out. But, only cause it's you :)
i know which band
and mike loves them!
i really wanna nudge guntrip
what band is it? I only have about 15 minutes left of procrastination before I have to write up two gigs! :)
but
you can't just rely on news mailouts either, i certainly don't read all of the ones i get, even those i signed up for. when i have done it this way i've received no feedback and no doubt the mails were probably instantly deleted if they weren't already directed to the junk folder.
you really need to contact people personally, and keep in contact, seek feedback etc, but i'm rubbish at this.
i guess it does depend on making contacts
a lot of people contact me directly so i always read their emails and respond. I have an email address on my myspace profile now so i get emails from unsigned bands as well asking for advice (as if i know!?). I always try to point them in decent directions and that.
I do know people that get so many emails tho they just delete them. I suppose it depends on who you are contacting. The further you are up that ladder, the less likely you are to have any time to be able to respond to messages.
That's true
But even with the time to do it it's a tricky one because you don't want to go pissing anyone off by hassling too much. That's why press agents can get away with charging so much, because they (in theory, at least) have good relationships with these people so can get away with bugging them a bit more than us strangers with our annoying emails
oh yeah
i know all this. i just took exception to the "there's no excuse really" comment and the idea that just because moshi moshi are an indie label that can get good coverage for their artists we all can ;)
which band GT?
:)
Kaiser Chiefs and Razorlight?
Surely that counts as narrower taste, not wider?
don't even think about getting signed
too many bands just want to be in the industry schmindustry and they suck!
first and foremost just work on being a good band, writing great songs, build up contacts, playing good gigs and not taking every single gig offered - pick and choose carefully.
if you're really good, word of mouth will follow and some decent press exposure too. keep writing, keep gigging, more contacts. people will come to you instead of you having to hassle them.
release a record on some indie label, then some major (or trendy indie looking but still major offshoot of a major) will come along and snap you up. job's a good un!
and then when you're inevitably dumped by said major,
you can go back to the indie but having had the benefit of tens of thousands of pounds spent on publicity for you.
but
even the majors have wizened up to that. i hear only 3 acts have been signed to majors so far this year and they signed less last year than ever before. this year i doubt more than 20 acts will be signed to majors in the uk.
but
didn't Clocks sign to Island recently, assuming that counts as a major that is ridiculous.
^
island is owned by universal music corp
This
is very true...its now more like news if a major signs a band rather than the actual band being the focus...
also if you've not read it, every band should read this
http://www.wired.com/entertainment/music/magazine/16-01/ff_byrne?currentPage=all
i think this advice goes for so many things
if you want to be in a band/ or be involved in the music business because of a perceived need for 'success' or greatness, then you're ultimately going to fall on your arse eventually.
Like sean says, I think the people who are willing to put up with the long haul, do it because they HAVE to or because they love it so much they can't NOT.
I have no idea how you get signed. Find a music journalist who likes your band and is willing to promote you, get a following on myspace. Add a bazillion friends to myspace, have a rich/ famous dad - it worked for Lily Allen!!!
If that is who you are, then you will find a way to get there. Even if you make a twat of yourself in the process. I'm constantly sending my shit to people to look at (I doubt they ever do and it probably ends up in the bin) but I feel like I'm at least being proactive in attaining my dreams... even if the reality of that is somewhat far removed.
I think in essence, even if you're good... you still need some of that magic sparkle dust from the good luck fairy, also known as 'being in the right place at the right time'.
"Add a bazillion friends to myspace, have a rich/ famous dad - it worked for Lily Allen!!!"
I've heard a lot of rumours that Lily Allen actually added a lot of people from EMI's or othersuch mailing lists to give the impression the day the press were looking at the site, that a lot of people were checking her out.
also arctic monkeys pretty sold out their first london gig, not because of london buzz but because they bought a busload of people along for a piss-up in london as if it were a pay-to-play gig.
the two things with both of these acts is that they were/are special. the buzz/maniacal science, just helped bring that to fruition.
Lily Allen is special?!
ummm... ok.
"Add a bazillion friends to myspace, have a rich/ famous dad - it worked for Lily Allen!!!"- that was my sarcastic sense of humour!!!
You told me that about Lily before. I know a lot of PR companies are a bit obsessed with adding friends on myspace - quantity over quality and that.
Arctic Monkeys did have a really good underground vibe going on before they got massive - mainly through the online press (I know the people who did their online). But yeh, bringing a busload of people to your gig = good thinking, I reckon.
Arctics are pretty special. I'm glad they've done well.
being "special" isn't enough ( nor necessary )
to make it...
And buzz has killed more bands that it has helped bands.
At the end, everything is a question of luck...
one person's 'special' is another person's Pidgeon Defectives
too true! :)
.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FeX0me9Iom4
I think
Your question really depends upon what you hope to achieve, as everyone before me has already said.
I think a common mistake a lot of bands make is thinking that by signing to a major label they've "made it", when in actual fact it's only just begun. The workload goes through the roof and the pressure, I can imagine, must be insane. The constant demands to deliver new and better material, all the promo which comes with it and if at the end of the day people decide not to buy your records, you're sacked, effectively. Depending on the deal you signed, this can cause more problems than the obvious disappointment of failiure, but can also lead to serious financial issues.
Wherever you want to take your music, one of the most important things you can do is be creative. I ranted about this on http://blogscarymonsters.blogspot.com last week but I'm currently getting somewhere in the region of 20 bands contacting me every day. Some write lovely emails and have clearly taken the time to research the label, others send generic messages to hundreds of people fishing for anything and a few think that adding you on Myspace and leaving an arrogant "we're the next big thing" comment on your page is the way forward. I'd be interested to know how many bands have actually been signed that way. I'd wager a man with no arms could count them on his fingers.
Attractive packaging of CDs is good. The aesthetic of a band is important, and by that I don't mean you have to be good looking, but things like your website design, your promo photos, the front which people will see, basically.
Getting frequent, and well suited shows is important, although not always as easy as it sounds, especially when you're starting out. Keep plugging away and you'll get there, though. I remember trying to book This Town Needs Guns first tour and really struggling just to get them just 4 shows. Now they're being offered things all of the time and could probably play 200 gigs a year if they wanted to.
Making friends with as many people as possible is good, too. And by that I don't mean go out and be horribly smarmy with industry folk, I mean wear a smile and be polite at all times. If someone takes the time to tell you they like what you're doing, appreciate that. Sounds obvious, but it's something some people don't bother with.
Having money to spend on things can help (and afterall, if you're in a band with 5 members, buying 200 blank CD-Rs and burning a few each takes very little time or cash) but it's certainly not essential. Learn to do things on a budget. Why spend £10k on advertising when 90% of the people seeing it don't even know who you are? Target your audience and find creative ways to reach them. Online media is brilliant for that. Myspace and Youtube have become a staple in every bands career and identity now, but there are many more options out there. You don't need to chuck cash at these things to make them work, just take some time to research and plan.
And as Sean said, don't do anything until you're ready. Take your time writing and rehearsing and get some tracks recorded which you're 100% proud of. If I get one more band email saying "listen to our new recording. It's only bass and drums at the moment, and it's far from being our best work, but we really think we're ready to be signed" I think I'll quit this business and move to a country where music is illegal.
slight digression here
What advice for the band that seems to have loads of ideas about musical direction but is to constipated to let go and try something. Loads of killer gear, big ideas and hopes but hardly anything to show. Having to learn drums is killing everything now. Please, what is a wanker to do? Serious answers please, and don't say quit- which I know is probably the best advice.
i liked your blog rant about bands contacting you
i get so many spam emails that include the phrase "are looking for a label to take them to the next level" that i want to weep.
haha
too many like that!
^
i'm still getting gig requests from bands eight months after my club night finished (i moved country)
the page even has "this club is officially dead, rip 2005 - 2007" in big bold capital letters, but they keep on coming
mimas
are coming to get you...
May 1st, they're in Oxford Kev!
Thankfully, I didn't see an email from Fine 69 (ooh, 69. how daring and rude of us) but well done on naming and shaming them!
Yeah I felt bad
But then I listened to their songs again
I think I might miss Mimas in Oxford, which I'm really gutted about. Going to see Copy Haho in London. Gonna try and do both gigs but I fear time is going to be against me!
My friends act, Heartbreak just got signed to do a x 4 LP deal
with Lex Records, who are a subsidiary of Warp. Warp are doing their music vid. I am so fucking pleased. They have worked hard and been an act, doing the circuit for at least four years now. It's very much about networking as well as talent. They deserve it. They have worked so hard and I am sooo pleased for them.
www.myspace.com/heartbreak1
if you really wanna get signed
that's a pretty good one to aim for! ;-)
Heartbreak will be a household name
watch this space.
Is that sarcasm?
I love this label and pretty much everything on it, but I never heard PJ and Duncan namechecking any of the acts;)
What about some backdoor
Like self release, self distribution and like that? Pipe dreams of the highest order?
..
if it doesn't come bursting out of you
in spite of everything,
don't do it.
unless it comes unasked out of your
heart and your mind and your mouth
and your gut,
don't do it.
if you have to sit for hours
staring at your computer screen
or hunched over your
typewriter
searching for words,
don't do it.
if you're doing it for money or
fame,
don't do it.
if you're doing it because you want
women in your bed,
don't do it.
if you have to sit there and
rewrite it again and again,
don't do it.
if it's hard work just thinking about doing it,
don't do it.
if you're trying to write like somebody
else,
forget about it.
if you have to wait for it to roar out of
you,
then wait patiently.
if it never does roar out of you,
do something else.
if you first have to read it to your wife
or your girlfriend or your boyfriend
or your parents or to anybody at all,
you're not ready.
don't be like so many writers,
don't be like so many thousands of
people who call themselves writers,
don't be dull and boring and
pretentious, don't be consumed with self-
love.
the libraries of the world have
yawned themselves to
sleep
over your kind.
don't add to that.
don't do it.
unless it comes out of
your soul like a rocket,
unless being still would
drive you to madness or
suicide or murder,
don't do it.
unless the sun inside you is
burning your gut,
don't do it.
when it is truly time,
and if you have been chosen,
it will do it by
itself and it will keep on doing it
until you die or it dies in you.
there is no other way.
and there never was.