Drowned in Sound

Search



rupert the sky

Bilge Pump: Rupert The Sky

1 vote
?
by Ben Patashnik
  • Type: Album
  • Release date: 28/04/2008
  • Label: Gringo

Ah, shouting. Leeds’ Bilge Pump certainly enjoy letting rip more often than not, as Rupert The Sky is characterised by discord. Their noisy, scrappy post-punk has more in common with contemporaries such as the late Mclusky than any other, arguably more canonical touchstones, but unfortunately doesn’t stand up all that well on its own two feet.

One thing Bilge Pump have in spades is personality, although that’s not entirely a good thing. “We were genuine, happy children / But our dad was a miserable cunt” goes ‘I Am Perfectly Fine’, but such moments of humour are rare and sadly lost amidst the clatter. ‘Can I Touch Your Leg’ starts with a series of howling, moaning guitars layered over one another that provides almost an oasis of calm when placed in the context of the album. But it’s over far too quickly and descends into – shock horror – yet more noisy riffs and purposefully atypical song structures. While there are moments when their desire to annoy and frustrate is what drives their music powerfully and well – ‘I Like Your Style’ is a truly funny, catchy little ditty that recalls what Eddie Argos might come up with if the rest of Art Brut had been brought up on Wire – on others it simply gets in the way. ‘The Fuckover’ and ‘Brown Ale For Sister Sarah’ each have the initial potential to be great, all pounding drums and pushy guitars that trip over one another in the race to get to the end of the song, but take seemingly intentional wrong turns, as if writing a song with a beginning, middle and end is verboten for Bilge Pump.

It’s a shame, because there’s more than enough evidence on Rupert The Sky that they could grow into being a fine underground band. When ‘Om Nom Savoy’ kicks in it’s a frenetic, jagged anti-pop song that is sadly spoilt by some wilfully oblique ranting about cleaning up the kitchen, and it perfectly encompasses both the good and bad sides of Bilge Pump. It’s like they’re scared of writing anything too uniform, so by shoehorning in a bunch of annoying non-sequiturs it’s their defence mechanism. Which is a shame, because this could’ve been belting.

  • Bilge Pump 5 / 10

Review 2

http://www.drownedinsound.com/articles/3226677

In the name of balanced opinions.


i agree

with the second review. great band, great album. and im not even in any way associated with them.


I was interested in seeing this review..

..I'm now disappointed but will read blindjoedeath's review next for a second opinion.

I've never actually heard the band before, just curious from what I've heard.


They're...

..awesome. Just don't try and figure it out, it's not art crit, it's rock music.


WOW!

Needless to say i'm a tad shocked by 5/10.

Bilge Pump have been around for a long time now and apparently the late John Peel had quite a taste for them.

They are awesome live, and an all round awesome band.

I suppose how i could see someone 'not getting it', but i certainly do! Phenomenal!


"Bilge Pump have been around for a long time now and apparently the late John Peel had quite a taste

This was in response to Ben Patashinik's comment about thier potential to grow into a fine underground band btw, which blindjoedeath has also picked up on in his review...

"Let Me Breath" came out about 5 years ago didn't it?


,

Let Me Breathe came out in 2002. They have been together for over 10 years. Of course, I think the review is so far off the mark to be almost laughable (McLusky!?). Really disappointed that DiS have tossed away such an awe-inspiring band. Oh well, have a listen yourself at http://www.last.fm/music/Bilge+Pump/Rupert+The+Sky


To be honest...

This album isn't whoa-there brilliant. Ben's 5 is perhaps a mite lower than I'd have gone in at, as there are moments aplenty to savour (and slightly crisper than those of Let Me Breathe), but to call this a straight-up 9 is to be blinkered by personal involvement. Yep. This review is balanced, and highlights enough plus points for those already familiar to know it's not a dip in form. Newcomers... well, after ten years shouldn't the band have cleaned up all the newcomers they're ever gonna get?

Hello Matt.


Not that I do not think...

...that Chris' user review raises worthwhile points, as I do.


In your opinion...

It isn't "whoa there brilliant" in your opinion and thats the point I raised in the review I tried to write. It fascinates me that as you put it "after 10 years shouldn't they have cleaned up all the newcomers" - well, no. Not if by circumstance and choice they not just go against the standardised way of promoting themselves but genuinely don't give a fuck about it.
This means all you have to judge them on is their record and that's something people find hard to do. They need more. They need an 'angle'. Bilge are always going to suffer because of that.
If someone reviews, say Lightning Bolt for example there is a certain amount of hype attached to that that leads the reviewer to not just review the record as an object but to review their thoughts about the band and what the band represents. These thoughts come from all manner of things they've read or heard, not just from the album concerned. If you don't have those things you have to review the record and nothing else and that's what leads to reviews like this which say more about the person who wrote it than the record they wrote it about.
I do have a personal involvement with this one but only as far as them being my favourite band, that's as personal as it gets. Anything I've ever done for them stems from that, and that includes writing things like this.


PS

That's not a diss (geddit?) on anyone either.


Mclusky?!

not heard this album yet, but they've been playing material off it live for a very long time, and i doubt a 5 is a fair score, they're a fantastic band.


The album is pretty good,

but they're sooooo much better in the flesh. Saw them a couple of months ago and they're still one of the most invigorating blasts of rock fun around.